Current:Home > StocksNY judge denies governor’s bid to toss suit challenging decision to halt Manhattan congestion fee-InfoLens
NY judge denies governor’s bid to toss suit challenging decision to halt Manhattan congestion fee
View Date:2024-12-23 15:36:24
NEW YORK (AP) — A New York judge on Friday denied Gov. Kathy Hochul’s request to toss out lawsuits challenging her decision to halt a new congestion fee for drivers into Manhattan.
Judge Arthur Engoron made the decision in a Manhattan court after hearing about two hours of arguments in lawsuits brought by transportation and environmental advocates that support the fee.
The tolling program, which had been set to start June 30, would have imposed on drivers entering the core of Manhattan a toll of about $15, depending on vehicle type, in order to generate about $1 billion annually for transit improvements.
Andrew Celli, a lawyer representing the City Club of New York, one of the local groups that has sued Hochul, said afterward that the judge’s ruling means the lawsuits will move forward and the governor will have to justify her actions in court.
“What the judge did here is he said that congestion pricing will not be delayed by legal technicalities,” he said outside court. “That’s a huge victory for people that care about the law and people that care about congestion pricing.”
Alan Schoenfeld, a lawyer representing Hochul and the state Department of Transportation in the lawsuits, didn’t immediately respond to an email seeking comment.
Groups challenging the governor’s decision, including the Riders Alliance, the Sierra Club and the New York City Environmental Justice Alliance, argue the Democrat violated the state’s laws and constitution when she indefinitely paused the fee just days before its planned launch.
Hochul at the time cited economic concerns, suggesting it wasn’t the right time to impose a new toll scheme as local businesses and residents were still recovering financially from the coronavirus pandemic.
In court Friday, Celli argued that state lawmakers deliberately did not give the governor’s office authority on when the fee would be imposed when it passed it into law in 2019.
Instead, he argued, the legislature charged the Triborough Bridge and Tunnel Authority, which oversees the bridges and tunnels in the New York City area, with making that final decision in order to remove politics from the equation.
“She doesn’t have the discretion,” Celli said.
But Schoenfeld said it was a “demonstrably false” to suggest that state lawmakers intended to put the tunnel and bridge authority “unilaterally” in charge of congestion pricing.
He argued that the law also recognizes the critical role the governor’s office and state DOT play in the process.
Engoron, at points in the hearing, appeared unmoved by Schoenfeld’s arguments.
He also joked at the outset of the hearing that he drove into Manhattan for the hearing and the traffic was terrible.
“Can’t anyone do anything about that?” Engoron said to laughs before launching into the proceedings.
Dror Ladin, a lawyer with Earthjustice, which represented some of the groups challenging Hochul, also argued that the months since the governor’s decision this summer have been damaging.
He says New Yorkers have dealt with more traffic, more negative health and environmental consequences from air pollution and further delays in desperately needed transit system upgrades.
“There’s a real harm here,” Ladin said.
___
Follow Philip Marcelo at twitter.com/philmarcelo.
veryGood! (9)
Related
- Traveling to Las Vegas? Here Are the Best Black Friday Hotel Deals
- Carefully planned and partly improvised: inside the Columbia protest that fueled a national movement
- NFL draft attendees down for 3rd straight year. J.J. McCarthy among those who didn’t go to Detroit
- After wake-up call at home, Celtics need to beat Heat in Game 3, quell potential panic
- 'He's driving the bus': Jim Harbaugh effect paying dividends for Justin Herbert, Chargers
- Florida man charged with first-degree murder in rape, killing of Madeline 'Maddie' Soto
- 18-year-old Bowie High School student shot, killed by another student in Texas, police say
- Hamas releases video of injured Israeli-American hostage Hersh Goldberg-Polin
- Republican Rep. Juan Ciscomani wins reelection to Arizona US House seat
- Horoscopes Today, April 25, 2024
Ranking
- Biden EPA to charge first-ever ‘methane fee’ for drilling waste by oil and gas companies
- Professor William Decker’s Bio
- Adobe's Photoshop upgrade reshapes images
- The hidden costs of unpaid caregiving in America
- USMNT Concacaf Nations League quarterfinal Leg 1 vs. Jamaica: Live stream and TV, rosters
- Man indicted in cold case killing of retired Indiana farmer found shot to death in his home
- Nick and Aaron Carter doc announced by 'Quiet on Set' network: See the trailer
- Giants place Blake Snell on 15-day IL with adductor strain
Recommendation
-
Kyle Richards Swears This Holiday Candle Is the Best Scent Ever and She Uses It All Year
-
Tony Khan, son of Jaguars owner, shows up to NFL draft with neck brace. Here's why.
-
Trump downplays deadly Charlottesville rally by comparing it to campus protests over Gaza war
-
Suspect in fatal shooting of ex-Saints player Will Smith sentenced to 25 years in prison
-
US Open finalist Taylor Fritz talks League of Legends, why he hated tennis and how he copied Sampras
-
Trading Trump: Truth Social’s first month of trading has sent investors on a ride
-
US abortion battle rages on with moves to repeal Arizona ban and a Supreme Court case
-
The Best Jean Shorts For Curvy Girls With Thick Thighs